From: Gary Gottlieb
To: Kiva Oraibi
Date: Jan 22, 2006 11:32 AM
Subject: Response to Your Blog of September 23, 2005
In your September 23, 2005 blog, you encouraged your readers to “choose a gastroenterologist who actually believes in science and not mythology,” based on a letter I wrote to the Arizona Daily Star. You apparently assume that I am not scientific because I believe that “Darwin's theory of cross-species evolution has never been proven, and thus is controversial.” There are many scientific theories that are controversial among scientists; that does not mean that they are based on mythology.
I challenge you to find any evidence that I believe in mythology based on this letter. True science has always been and always will be, I hope, based on evidence. It is a scientific fact that Darwin’s theories about the origins of life have never been proven. It is also true that there are many scientists with impressive credentials who have written books challenging Darwin’s theories. For example, (1) Michael J. Behe, Professor of Biochemistry at Lehigh University (Darwin's Black Box) and (2) Daniel C. Dennett, Distinguished Arts and Sciences Professor and Director for Center of Cognitive Studies at Tufts University (Darwin's Dangerous Idea).
Those who want to believe that Darwin’s ideas have been unequivocally proven and accepted by the scientific community are acting more out of faith than out of rigorous scientific method. Open-minded scientists are motivated by a quest for the truth, wherever that will lead, rather than by a desire to prove what they already believe.
My original letter to the editor was edited down to their specified length. In that original letter I stated that in the future, scientific research may eventually come up with evidence that proves Darwin’s theories. Until then, the theories should be taught as theories and not as fact. Perhaps that will motivate students to pursue that line of scientific research.
My own background is thoroughly immersed in science and research. The following excerpts from my CV will attest to my rigorous training and research background:
EDUCATION AND TRAINING
Undergraduate The Johns Hopkins University
1965 - 1969 Baltimore, Maryland A.B., Liberal Arts
(Pre-Medical), 1969
Graduate Temple University School of Medicine
1969 - 1973 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
M.D., 1973
Postgraduate Internship in Medicine
1973 – 1974 Hospitals of the University Health Center
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
James J. Leonard, MD, Chairman
1974 - 1976 Residency in Internal Medicine
Hospitals of the University Health Center
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
James J. Leonard, MD, Chairman
1976 - 1978 Fellowship in Gastroenterology
Hospitals of the University Health Center
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Roger Lester, MD, Director
PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES
1978 - 1983 Assistant Professor of Medicine, Division of
Gastroenterology, University of Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania
1978 - 1983 Chief, Gastroenterology Section, Medical Svc.,
Veterans Administration Medical Center,
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
1981 - 1983 Medical Director, Nutrition Support Service,
Veterans Administration Medical Center,
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
1978 - 1983 Full-time Active Staff, Gastroenterology,
Presbyterian-University Hospital
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
1983 - Present Private Practice in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Tucson.
PUBLICATIONS
1. Gottlieb GP, Turnheim K, Frizzel RA, and Schultz SG.
P-chloromercuribenzene sulfonate (PCMBS) blocks and reverses the
effect of amiloride on sodium transport across rabbit colon in
vitro. Biophysical J 1978; 22:125-129.
2. Van Thiel DH, Lipsitz HD, Porter LE, Schade RR, Gottlieb GP, and
Graham TO. Clinical Conference. Gastrointestinal and hepatic manifestations of
chronic alcoholism. Gastroenterology 1981; 81:594-615.
3. Openbrier DR, Irwin MM, Rogers RM, Gottlieb GP, Dauber JH, Van
Thiel DH, and Pennock BE. Nutrition and lung function in emphysema
and chronic bronchitis. Chest 1983; 83:17-22.
4. Stanley MM, et al. Peritoneovenous shunting as compared with
medical treatment in patients with alcoholic cirrhosis and massive
ascites. New Engl J Med 1989; 321:1632-1638.
5. Euler AR, et al. A report of three multiclinic trials
evaluating arbaprostil in arthritic patients with ASA/NSAID gastric
mucosal damage. Gastroenterology 1990; 98:1549-1557.
Wow, all that good science learnin', and he still believes in superstition. Because I'm sorry, I don't buy that he's just concerned with the scientific purity of calling "Darwinism" "just" a "theory". That's Creationist/Intelligent Design/Dominionist speak; it's anti-intellectual fundamentalism that is ashamed to state what it truly is: Darwin is attacked because the Christian Right wants to push their religious views in school, and they hold such an inflexible and backwards of the world that they have to tear down anything they view as a threat to that flawed worldview.
I'm waiting for him to prove me wrong, and deny that his religion shapes his view of Darwinism. I doubt he will. (PS: Yes, I know Gottlieb sounds Jewish.)